I think Andreas' comment was of a
'student pilot' flying for his Silver Distance and went 'in team' for 570 km....
I have heard many times (very regretfully) of short experience pilots being 'helped' around a course by their buddies. The radio calls of 'time to leave this one' and 'I now have six knots over here ahead of you'...are unmistakable. It is fine to have a learning experience of a team flown task. I do not object to this.
My regrets are only that I think it seriously undermines the value of the FAI badge system. Badge flights were intended to be filed as a self achievement, not a group effort. And, yes, it is normal soaring practice to 'notice' other gliders marking lift. But it is very different to 'team fly' a task for an achievement award.
Those of us who are observers are obligated to uphold the integrity of the badge system. Trying 50 km in a DG-300 is not a very huge challenge..... I wonder if he was 'proud' of 'his' achievement. I wonder if the observer really felt like they did their duty. Apparently, in his neighborhood, everyone knows the real story.... he was handheld around the kilometers.....
Cindy B
Caracole Soaring 22570 Airport Way California City, CA 93505 Phone/Fax 760-373-1019
http://members.aol.com/soarca/caracole.htm